All-Presidents Athletic Conference
2019
| Nick Holmes | Honorable Mention |
| Andrew Smith | Honorable Mention |
| Andrew Smith | All-Sportsmanship Team |
All-Ohio River Athletic Conference
2015
| Jake Holland | Second Team |
| Jordan Horne | Second Team |
| Jacob Schiffer | Honorable Mention |
| Colton Reeves | Honorable Mention |
| John Page | Honorable Mention |
| Anthony Smith | Honorable Mention |
| Bryan Uth | Honorable Mention |
| Brenden Wesslls | All-Sportsmanship Team |
2016
| Jake Holland | Second Team |
| Dominic Halstead | Second Team |
| Steve Pluas | Honorable Mention |
| Sean Rhodes | Honorable Mention |
| Jacob Schiffer | Honorable Mention |
| Bryan Uth | Honorable Mention |
| Sean Rhodes | All-Sportsmanship Team |
2017
| Jake Holland | Second Team |
| Dominic Halstead | Second Team |
| Shaka Conteh | Second Team |
| Cody Bergman | Honorable Mention |
| Caleb Staudenbaur | Honorable Mention |
| Will Gatling | Honorable Mention |
| Cody Bergman | All-Sportsmanship Team |
2018
| Bryan Uth | Second Team |
| Majied Bey | Second Team |
| Shaka Conteh | Second Team |
| Caleb Staudenbaur | Honorable Mention |
| Sean Rhodes | All-Sportsmanship Team |